Charleston Mix monogram logoCharleston MixAll-natural cocktail mixers

Journal

Key Lime Pie Cocktail w/ Bubba’s Burnt Sugar

Key Lime Pie Cocktail with Bubba’s Burnt Sugar + Charleston Mix Classic Margarita—tart, creamy, and balanced. Get the recipe.

By Charleston Mix9 min read
Golden cocktail over ice with a graham-cracker rim and lime garnish, beside fresh limes and graham crackers, with text reading “Key Lime Pie Cocktail with Bubba’s Burnt Sugar."

Some drinks are trying to be impressive. This one is just trying to make you smile.

We’ve been playing with Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon and Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix and landed on a super simple 1:1 cocktail that somehow tastes like a dessert moment. Not in a heavy way. More like that familiar combination you get from key lime pie. Bright citrus, sweet caramelized sugar vibes, then the graham cracker on the rim pulling it all together.

So we started calling it The Southern Charmer.

And the best part is you can serve it two ways without changing the recipe at all. Make it a full size cocktail for porch sipping. Or shake up a quick chilled shot situation for a party. Same ratio, same flavor, same graham cracker rim.

One little note before we get into it. This drink is reminiscent of key lime pie. It does not contain key lime juice, cream, or actual pie. It’s just the way the flavors land together. That’s the magic.

What it tastes like (and why it works)

Here’s what’s happening, basically.

  • Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix brings that bright, clean citrus and tangy zip. The kind that makes your mouth wake up a bit.
  • Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon brings warmth and sweetness, but it’s not simple syrup sweetness. It’s that toasted, caramelized, almost brûléed thing that reads as dessert without trying too hard.
  • The graham cracker rim is the “crust.” Not subtle either. You get aroma and texture right up front, then little crumbs with the sip.

Put them together and your brain goes, wait. This is giving key lime pie energy. Not literally. Just that same contrast. Tart and sweet, bright and cozy, with a crumbly edge.

If you're interested in trying out this unique cocktail blend yourself, consider experimenting with other variations of the margarita mix such as the Peach Margarita Mix or even the Spicy Margarita. For an even more delightful twist on this recipe, you might want to check out our Burnt Sugar Margarita recipe which incorporates similar elements for an equally satisfying experience!

Ingredients (you only need a few)

For the full size cocktail (1 drink)

  • 2 oz Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon
  • 2 oz Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix (or try variations like the Frozen Strawberry Margarita, Harbor Margarita, or Honeydew Cilantro Margarita for a twist)
  • Finely crushed graham crackers, for rimming
  • Lime wedge, for moistening the rim
  • Ice, for shaking and for serving
  • Optional: a small lime wedge or wheel for garnish (totally optional)

For the shot version (makes 2 shots)

  • 1 oz Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon
  • 1 oz Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix
  • Finely crushed graham crackers, for rimming
  • Lime wedge, for moistening the rims
  • Ice, for shaking

Same 1:1 ratio, just scaled down.

How to make the graham cracker rim (this is the whole vibe)

If you skip the rim, the drink still tastes good. But if you do the rim, it becomes the thing people talk about. Also it takes maybe 30 seconds.

  1. Crush the graham crackers finely.
  2. You want a sandy texture, not big chunks. A zip top bag and a rolling pin works. A food processor works faster. Just don’t overthink it.
  3. Pour the crumbs onto a small plate.
  4. Make a thin, even layer wide enough for your glass.
  5. Moisten the edge of your glass with a lime wedge.
  6. Lightly. You’re not soaking it. Just enough so the crumbs stick.
  7. Dip the rim into the graham cracker crumbs.
  8. Gently rotate and press a little so it holds. Tap off any loose crumbs.

That’s it. Now your drink has a crust.

The Southern Charmer (full size cocktail)

This is the one you make when you want to actually sit with it. Rocks glass, fresh ice, graham rim, the whole deal.

What you’ll use

  • Cocktail shaker
  • Jigger or measuring tool
  • Strainer
  • Rocks glass

Recipe

  • 2 oz Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon
  • 2 oz Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix

Steps

  1. Rim a rocks glass with graham crackers.
  2. Do the lime wedge thing, dip into finely crushed graham crackers. Set aside.
  3. Fill a shaker with ice.
  4. A good amount. You want it cold and properly diluted, not lukewarm and sharp.
  5. Add 2 oz bourbon + 2 oz margarita mix.
  6. Keep it equal parts. This is where the balance comes from.
  7. Shake hard for about 10 to 12 seconds.
  8. You’re chilling it fast and smoothing the edges.
  9. Add fresh ice to your prepared rocks glass.
  10. Strain into the glass over fresh ice.
  11. Try not to splash the rim too much. It’s fine if it happens. But that first clean sip with the graham edge is kind of the point.
  12. Optional: Add a lime wedge on the side if you want it to look a little dressed up.

Serving note

If you’re making a couple of these in a row, rim all the glasses first. Then shake each drink fresh. The rim stays crisp, and the drink stays icy cold.

The Southern Charmer (chilled shot version)

This is for the “everyone’s in the kitchen now” moment. Or the pre dinner cheers. Or honestly, when you want the flavor without committing to a whole cocktail.

And yes, we’re still rimming shot glasses. It sounds extra. It is extra. But it’s also the fun part.

What you’ll use

  • Cocktail shaker
  • Strainer
  • 2 shot glasses

Recipe (makes two shots)

  • 1 oz Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon
  • 1 oz Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix

Steps

  1. Rim two shot glasses with graham crackers.
  2. Lightly moisten each rim with a lime wedge, then dip into finely crushed graham crackers. Set aside.
  3. Fill a shaker with ice.
  4. Add 1 oz bourbon + 1 oz margarita mix.
  5. Shake hard for about 10 seconds.
  6. The goal is very cold, very fast.
  7. Strain and divide evenly between the two shot glasses.
  8. Go slow. If you pour too aggressively you can knock crumbs off the rim. Still tastes great, just looks a little chaotic.

Shot serving note

Serve immediately. This one is best right after shaking when it’s frosty cold and the rim is still dry and crisp.

Why the 1:1 ratio matters here

Equal parts sounds almost too simple, but it’s what makes the drink click.

  • Too much margarita mix and the citrus takes over, you lose the burnt sugar warmth.
  • Too much bourbon and it can feel heavy, like you’re missing that pie like brightness.

At 1:1, you get this clean balance. Citrus first. Then that caramelized sweetness. Then the graham cracker finishes it. The whole thing reads as dessert adjacent without being sugary in a cloying way.

Tips to make it feel like a “real” cocktail (even though it’s easy)

A few little things that make a difference.

Shake with plenty of ice

If you’re light on ice, the drink won’t chill as quickly, and you’ll get a harsher sip. A full shaker makes it colder and smoother.

Use fresh ice in the serving glass

Shaking ice is already partially melted and cracked down. Fresh ice keeps the drink crisp, and it looks better too.

Crush the graham crackers finer than you think

Big crumbs fall off. Fine crumbs cling. Also fine crumbs give you that even “crust” effect, which is what makes it feel like the key lime pie moment you’re aiming for.

Rim only the outside edge (if you want to be neat)

You can dip the whole rim if you want. But if you keep the crumbs mostly on the outside, you get the aroma and texture without graham bits floating into the drink.

When to serve it

This is one of those cocktails that doesn’t need a special occasion, but it also works for one.

  • After dinner when everyone wants “something sweet” but you don’t want to bake.
  • Brunch, honestly. It’s bright and citrusy, but still warm because of the bourbon.
  • Game day, backyard hangs, beach weekends. It’s a crowd pleaser.
  • Holiday parties, where you want an easy signature drink that feels a little different.

Full size for sipping, shots for cheering. Same recipe. No extra planning.

Quick recipe recap

Full size cocktail

  • Rim a rocks glass with lime wedge + finely crushed graham crackers
  • Shake with ice: 2 oz Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon + 2 oz Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix
  • Strain into the graham cracker rimmed rocks glass over fresh ice

Chilled shot version (makes 2)

  • Rim two shot glasses with lime wedge + finely crushed graham crackers
  • Shake with ice: 1 oz Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon + 1 oz Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix
  • Strain and divide evenly into the two shot glasses

If you make The Southern Charmer, don’t be surprised when somebody says, why does this taste like key lime pie. And then immediately asks for another.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

What is The Southern Charmer cocktail and what makes it unique?

The Southern Charmer is a simple 1:1 cocktail made with Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon and Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix. It tastes like a dessert moment reminiscent of key lime pie, combining bright citrus, sweet caramelized sugar vibes, and a graham cracker rim that adds aroma and texture, creating a tart and sweet contrast that's both bright and cozy.

What ingredients do I need to make The Southern Charmer full-size cocktail?

To make one full-size Southern Charmer cocktail, you'll need 2 oz Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon, 2 oz Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix (or variations like Frozen Strawberry Margarita or Honeydew Cilantro Margarita), finely crushed graham crackers for rimming, a lime wedge to moisten the rim, ice for shaking and serving, and optionally a lime wedge or wheel for garnish.

How do I prepare the graham cracker rim for The Southern Charmer?

To make the graham cracker rim: finely crush graham crackers to a sandy texture; spread crumbs evenly on a small plate; moisten the edge of your glass lightly with a lime wedge; dip and gently rotate the rim into the crumbs so they stick; tap off excess crumbs. This adds aroma, texture, and completes the 'crust' effect reminiscent of key lime pie.

Can The Southern Charmer be served in different ways without changing the recipe?

Yes! The Southern Charmer can be served as a full-size cocktail in a rocks glass over fresh ice for porch sipping or as quick chilled shots for parties. Both use the same 1:1 ratio of bourbon to margarita mix with the graham cracker rim intact, delivering consistent flavor regardless of serving style.

What flavors does Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon bring to The Southern Charmer?

Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon contributes warmth and sweetness with toasted, caramelized notes similar to brûléed sugar. This gives the drink dessert-like qualities without being heavy or overly sweet like simple syrup, perfectly complementing the bright citrus from the margarita mix.

Are there variations or other recipes similar to The Southern Charmer I can try?

Absolutely! You can experiment with other Charleston Mix margarita variations such as Peach Margarita Mix or Spicy Margarita. For another delightful twist using similar elements, check out the Burnt Sugar Margarita recipe which also combines burnt sugar bourbon with margarita mix for an equally satisfying experience.

Good questions

Before you pour.

What is The Southern Charmer cocktail and what makes it unique?

The Southern Charmer is a simple 1:1 cocktail made with Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon and Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix. It tastes like a dessert moment reminiscent of key lime pie, combining bright citrus, sweet caramelized sugar vibes, and a graham cracker rim that adds aroma and texture, creating a tart and sweet contrast that's both bright and cozy.

What ingredients do I need to make The Southern Charmer full-size cocktail?

To make one full-size Southern Charmer cocktail, you'll need 2 oz Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon, 2 oz Charleston Mix Classic Margarita Mix (or variations like Frozen Strawberry Margarita or Honeydew Cilantro Margarita), finely crushed graham crackers for rimming, a lime wedge to moisten the rim, ice for shaking and serving, and optionally a lime wedge or wheel for garnish.

How do I prepare the graham cracker rim for The Southern Charmer?

To make the graham cracker rim: finely crush graham crackers to a sandy texture; spread crumbs evenly on a small plate; moisten the edge of your glass lightly with a lime wedge; dip and gently rotate the rim into the crumbs so they stick; tap off excess crumbs. This adds aroma, texture, and completes the 'crust' effect reminiscent of key lime pie.

Can The Southern Charmer be served in different ways without changing the recipe?

Yes! The Southern Charmer can be served as a full-size cocktail in a rocks glass over fresh ice for porch sipping or as quick chilled shots for parties. Both use the same 1:1 ratio of bourbon to margarita mix with the graham cracker rim intact, delivering consistent flavor regardless of serving style.

What flavors does Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon bring to The Southern Charmer?

Bubba’s Burnt Sugar Bourbon contributes warmth and sweetness with toasted, caramelized notes similar to brûléed sugar. This gives the drink dessert-like qualities without being heavy or overly sweet like simple syrup, perfectly complementing the bright citrus from the margarita mix.

Are there variations or other recipes similar to The Southern Charmer I can try?

Absolutely! You can experiment with other Charleston Mix margarita variations such as Peach Margarita Mix or Spicy Margarita. For another delightful twist using similar elements, check out the Burnt Sugar Margarita recipe which also combines burnt sugar bourbon with margarita mix for an equally satisfying experience.

Ready to pour?

Get the mix. Start the ritual.

Pick up a bottle at a retailer near you or order online and have it delivered to your door.